We may earn a small commission if you click links and make a purchase. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Last Updated on November 19, 2023

American Mint is a well-known entity in the coin collecting world. Like many businesses, it relies heavily on its reputation, which is often shaped by customer feedback and reviews.

In the age of the internet, reviews play a pivotal role in shaping a company’s image. Reviews not only provide insights into the experiences of previous customers but also offer potential customers a glimpse into what they might expect.

This article delves deep into the reviews of American Mint, especially those found on the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

Key Highlights

  • Diverse Product Range: American Mint offers a wide variety of collectibles, from gold, silver, and platinum coins to unique commemoratives and rare U.S. currency, catering to both seasoned collectors and novices.
  • Quality and Craftsmanship: With a commitment to excellence, American Mint’s products stand out for their intricate designs, historical significance, and meticulous craftsmanship.
  • Collector’s Haven: Beyond coins, American Mint provides collectors with essential accessories to preserve and showcase their collection, ensuring that every piece retains its value and beauty over time.

gold ira investing kit blue

What is American Mint?

American Mint is a prominent company specializing in the sale of collectible coins, knives, die-cast replicas, and other related products. Established with the aim to provide collectors with high-quality products at affordable prices, American Mint has garnered attention from both avid collectors and casual buyers.

Their offerings range from historical coins commemorating significant events to unique collectibles celebrating various themes and personalities.

While the company boasts a vast array of products, it’s essential for potential buyers to understand the company’s background, its reputation in the market, and the experiences of previous customers.

This article delves deep into the reviews and feedback associated with American Mint, providing a comprehensive overview for those considering making a purchase.

American Mint Product Offerings

gold and silver bars in a large vault

American Mint is a renowned platform for coin enthusiasts and collectors. They offer a wide range of products that cater to various interests and preferences. Here’s a detailed look into their product offerings:

1. Gold Coins

American Mint offers an exquisite collection of gold coins. These coins are not just a symbol of wealth but also represent historical events, iconic figures, and significant milestones. Collectors can find a diverse range of designs and themes that cater to different tastes.

2. Silver Coins

Silver coins from American Mint are known for their intricate designs and high-quality craftsmanship. These coins often feature historical events, national symbols, and iconic figures. They are a popular choice among collectors due to their beauty and value.

3. Platinum Coins

For those who prefer the luster of platinum, American Mint has a selection of platinum coins. These coins are a testament to the mint’s commitment to quality and design excellence.

4. U.S. Currency

American Mint also offers a collection of U.S. currency. This includes both coins and paper money that have been in circulation in the past. Collectors can find rare and unique pieces that hold significant historical value.

5. Commemoratives

Commemorative coins and products are a significant part of American Mint’s offerings. These items are crafted to honor important events, individuals, and milestones. They are not just collectibles but also pieces of history that tell a story.

6. Collectibles

Apart from coins, American Mint also offers a range of other collectibles. This includes items like knives, bowie knives, daggers, and keepsake boxes. Each product is crafted with precision and represents a theme or story.

7. Collector’s Accessories

For collectors who want to preserve and display their collection, American Mint offers a range of accessories. This includes:

  • Cotton Gloves
  • Vinyl Coin Pouches
  • Coin Capsules of various sizes
  • Coin Sleeves
  • Coin Albums
  • Premium Knife Wall Display

These accessories are essential for preserving the appearance of collectibles and protecting their long-term value.

8. Rare and Unique Coins

American Mint’s Rare and Unique Coins Department offers coins that are hard to find elsewhere. These coins were almost all melted in 1933, making them extremely valuable and sought after. The department provides personal attention from a Senior Account Executive, ensuring that collectors find the coins they are looking for.

In conclusion, American Mint offers a diverse range of products for collectors. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, American Mint has something for everyone. Their commitment to quality and authenticity makes them a trusted choice for collectors worldwide.

Does American Mint Offer a Precious Metals IRA?

documents from the goldco investing kit

While American Mint is renowned for its diverse range of collectibles and coins, it’s essential to determine if they offer a Precious Metals Individual Retirement Account (IRA).

A Precious Metals IRA allows individuals to diversify their retirement savings by investing in physical gold, silver, platinum, or palladium. As of the information available, it’s not explicitly mentioned whether American Mint provides this service.

If you’re considering investing in a Precious Metals IRA, it’s advisable to directly contact American Mint or consult their official website for detailed information.

If you’re looking for a top-rated Gold IRA company, Goldco is our current top pick:

#1 for Gold IRAs
#1 Rated Gold IRA Company
9.8/10Our Score

Goldco has some of the highest marks across the industry for customer service and integrity, including an A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau.

  • A+ Rating from Better Business Bureau 
  • AAA Rating from Business Consumer Alliance
  • Get up to $10,000 in Free Silver with Qualifying Purchase
  • Easy 3-Step Process to Get Started

"The crew at Goldco are professional and accommodating, extremely helpful and very easy to work with. My service rep, Tony Pino, was always available and willing to answer/explian any questions. Highly recommend them." -Mark G.

Overview of American Mint Reviews from BBB (Better Business Bureau)

The Better Business Bureau, commonly referred to as BBB, is a non-profit organization that has been setting standards for ethical business behavior for over a century. They provide a platform for customers to share their experiences, both positive and negative, with businesses.

At the time of publication American Mint was an accredited BBB business.

Here’s a summary of some of the reviews from customers who shared their experiences with American Mint on BBB:

  • Ernest H’s Experience:
    • Ernest warns potential customers after he lost $199 due to unresponsive customer service. He emphasizes, “I WILL NEVER ORDER ANYTHING FROM THEM AGAIN. PLEASE BEWARE IF YOU ORDER FROM THEM.
  • Christopher S’s Feedback:
    • Christopher highlights a misleading promotion where he was billed $85.16 for coins he thought were priced at $6.95. He labels the company as a “scam company” and advises others to avoid it.
  • Glenn V.’s Review:
    • Glenn received merchandise he never ordered. Despite multiple attempts, he struggled to reach the company. When he finally did, they disputed his claims. He warns others, calling them “total scammers!
  • Rick G.’s Experience:
    • Rick expresses his embarrassment for falling for what he believes is a scam. He warns others about the quality of the coins, urging them to “RUN RUN RUN.”
  • Ron G’s Feedback:
    • Ron points out that most items are LAYERED. He criticizes the advertising tactics that make products seem like they’re 99% gold or silver. He strongly advises against ordering from them, referring to them as “CROOKS.”
  • Rocky & Deborah C’s Review:
    • After purchasing a single coin, they received additional items and bills. Despite their efforts to stop communication, the company persisted. They describe their experience as terrible and advise others not to deal with American Mint.
  • Thomas W’s Feedback:
    • Thomas shares his disappointment after a local pawn business valued his $2000 worth of American Mint’s gold coins at only 25 cents each. He also mentions challenges with the company’s return process.
  • Walter K’s Review:
    • Walter describes the company’s sales tactics as “very deceitful” and requests to be removed from their list.
  • Robert N’s Experience:
    • Robert feels that he was scammed through a scratch ticket promotion. Despite winning a discount, he was billed the full amount.
  • Eric F’s Feedback:
    • Eric expresses regret for doing business with American Mint. He criticizes their continuous mailings and product issues, vowing never to deal with them again.

These reviews provide a snapshot of the experiences of some customers with American Mint. While reviews are subjective and based on individual experiences, they offer valuable insights for potential customers.

Common Themes in Reviews

While individual experiences vary, certain themes consistently emerge from the reviews of American Mint. These recurring issues provide potential customers with areas to be cautious about:

  • Unsolicited Items and Bills:
    • A significant number of reviewers mentioned receiving items they never ordered. This was often followed by bills for these unsolicited items, leading to confusion and frustration.
    • Advice: Always double-check any order confirmations and be wary of any promotions that might sign you up for recurring shipments.
  • Misleading Promotions and Pricing:
    • Several customers felt deceived by promotions that seemed too good to be true. Whether it was a scratch ticket promotion or a special coin offer, the end result was often a bill much higher than expected.
    • Advice: Read the fine print of any promotion and be skeptical of deals that seem too advantageous.
  • Product Quality Concerns:
    • Some reviewers expressed disappointment with the quality of the coins they received. Descriptions like “layered” were used, suggesting the coins weren’t as valuable as they appeared.
    • Advice: Research the product thoroughly before purchasing and consider seeking third-party appraisals for valuable items.

How American Mint Compares to Other Coin Dealers

The coin collecting world is vast, with numerous dealers offering a range of products. How does American Mint stack up against its competitors?

  • Reputation and Reviews:
    • While American Mint has a significant online presence, its reviews on platforms like the BBB highlight some areas of concern. It’s essential to compare these reviews with those of other coin dealers to get a comprehensive picture.
  • Product Range:
    • American Mint offers a wide variety of coins, from historical pieces to commemorative items. However, the quality and authenticity of these coins, as highlighted by some reviewers, might differ from other established dealers.
  • Pricing and Promotions:
    • While promotions can be enticing, it’s crucial to ensure that the final price matches expectations. Some customers felt that American Mint’s promotions were misleading, a concern that might not be as prevalent with other dealers.
  • Customer Service:
    • Effective communication and responsive customer service are vital in any business. Some reviewers felt that American Mint fell short in this area, especially when dealing with issues related to unsolicited items or billing.

Advice: Always do thorough research before committing to any coin dealer. Read reviews, compare prices, and ensure that the dealer is reputable and trustworthy.

American Mint Pros and Cons


  1. Diverse Product Range: From gold and silver coins to rare U.S. currency and unique commemoratives, American Mint offers something for every collector.
  2. Quality Craftsmanship: Their products are known for their intricate designs and meticulous detailing, reflecting a commitment to excellence.
  3. Collector’s Accessories: American Mint provides essential accessories for collectors, ensuring the preservation and display of their valuable items.
  4. Historical Significance: Many of their products, especially commemoratives, hold historical value, offering collectors a tangible connection to the past.


  1. Mixed Reviews: As seen from various platforms, some customers have had issues with unsolicited items, billing, and perceived product value.
  2. Promotion Clarity: Some promotions might appear misleading, leading to unexpected costs for the buyer.
  3. Product Authenticity Concerns: There have been concerns about the authenticity and quality of certain items, especially those labeled as “layered.”

Recommendations for Potential Customers

Considering the feedback and experiences shared by previous customers, here are some recommendations for those considering making a purchase from American Mint:

  • Research Before Purchasing:
    • Dive deep into product descriptions, reviews, and any associated promotions. Knowledge is power, and the more you know, the better equipped you’ll be to make informed decisions.
  • Read the Fine Print:
    • Promotions can be enticing, but they can also be misleading. Ensure you understand all terms and conditions before committing to a purchase.
  • Be Cautious with Promotions:
    • If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Be wary of promotions that might have hidden terms or lead to unsolicited items and bills.


Reviews offer invaluable insights into a company’s operations, product quality, and customer service. While individual experiences vary, patterns can emerge that provide potential customers with a clearer picture.

In the case of American Mint, while they offer a wide range of products and have a significant online presence, it’s crucial for customers to approach with caution, armed with knowledge and a healthy dose of skepticism.

Always prioritize research and due diligence before making any purchase.

gold ira investing kit blue


  • Q1: Are all products from American Mint genuine?
    • While American Mint offers a range of products, some customers have raised concerns about the authenticity and quality of certain items. It’s essential to do thorough research and, if possible, get a third-party appraisal for valuable items.
  • Q2: How does American Mint handle unsolicited items and billing?
    • Several reviews highlighted issues with receiving unsolicited items followed by bills. It’s advisable to double-check any order confirmations and be cautious of promotions that might sign you up for recurring shipments.
  • Q3: Can I return items to American Mint?
    • Based on customer feedback, returning items can be a point of contention. Before making a purchase, ensure you understand the return policy and any associated costs.
  • Q4: Are the promotions from American Mint genuine?
    • Some customers felt misled by certain promotions. Always read the fine print and be skeptical of deals that seem too good to be true.